The National Association of Forensic Historians TM

Combating the denial of historical facts via the scientific method TM

* * * * *

THE MAGICALLY DISAPPEARING MASS GRAVES MYSTERY

According to orthodox historians, at Treblinka, the Germans allegedly buried hundreds of thousands of bodies in six alleged “huge mass graves;” then, they allegedly dug up and burned the bodies; then, they allegedly reinterred all the remaining tons of bones and teeth into the same alleged “huge mass graves;” then, they allegedly covered the millions of pounds of evidence with a layer of soil; thus, the Germans, allegedly, “magically obliterated” the phantom “huge mass graves.” If you’re unfamiliar with this so-called “historical fact,” you can learn the forensic arguments HERE:

“This is the biggest cemetery [in Poland]… Within this area were [6] enormous pits… all of them were utterly eradicated… obliterated… Nothing remains - nothing.”

Nothing remains? Who in their right mind could believe this nonsensical “magically disappearing mass graves / bodies” story? Everyone knows that at every crime scene - EVIDENCE IS LEFT BEHIND: “Cremated remains weigh between three and nine pounds.” So in order to believe the absurd Treblinka mass burial claims, you must accept this as gospel: The Germans, by simply putting a layer of soil over six “huge mass graves” containing millions of pounds of bone fragments and tens of millions of teeth, “utterly eradicated” the biggest cemetery in Poland.

Utterly eradicated? How about utter nonsense? It’s understandable when a toddler believes that he’s made himself invisible while playing peek-a-boo by covering his eyes, but how do you explain the insanity of those who believe that a layer of soil can make millions of pounds of evidence magically disappear? To put this utterly unbelievable story in perspective, it’s like someone claiming that they could bury every single man, women and child in Montana - in an area the size of a football field - without leaving an iota of physical evidence. How can anyone in their right mind believe the childish notion that you can make something magically disappear by simply covering it with dirt?

* * * * *

WHAT KIND OF “TRUTH” REQUIRES LIES TO DEFEND IT?

Lest you think there must be some truth to this nonsensical canard

(That’s the psychology of the big-lie technique at work)

The National Association of Forensic Historians TM presents

THE N.A.F.H. CRIME SCENE INVESTIGATION CHALLENGE TM

$54,000.00

REWARD

For proving - just 1 / 1,000 of 1 % - of the magically disappearing mass grave claims

WHAT KIND OF “TRUTH” REQUIRES LAWS TO PROTECT IT?

* * * * *

THE 54 MAGICALLY DISAPPEARING “HUGE MASS GRAVES”

The alleged site of the “huge mass graves”	The number of alleged “huge mass graves”	The number alleged to be buried at each site	The alleged method used to magically “obliterate” all the physical evidence
Treblinka	6	900,000 *	Dig the bodies out of the alleged “huge mass graves;” then burn them on pyres made from railroad rails; then throw all the teeth and bones back into the same alleged “huge mass graves;” then cover all the “evidence” with a layer of soil.
Belzec	33	600,000 *
Sobibor	10	250,000 *
Chelmno	5	152,000 *
* * * * *	Total - 54	Total - 1,902,000 - * Source - Michael Shermer

Do you really believe that 1.9 million bodies could just magically disappear without leaving a trace?

The alleged site of the “huge mass graves”	Weight of the alleged remains that would have been left behind IF the story is true	The number of teeth that would be mixed in with the alleged millions of pounds of bone fragments
Treblinka	6.570 million pounds *	28.800 million
Belzec	4.380 million pounds *	19.200 million
Sobibor	1.825 million pounds *	8.000 million
Chelmno	1.110 million pounds *	4.864 million
* Calculations are derived from figures used by Arnulf Neumaier (see below)

To illustrate just how easy it is to debunk the big-lie that burning bodies makes them magically disappear, look at the following from Arnulf Neumaier’s treatise on TREBLINKA: “Regarding the claim that the corpses were eliminated completely without any trace, we must consider the quantity of the remains… It must be noted that under the conditions specified... the bones would not have turned to ash, but would have remained as bones.”

NOTE: You do understand that even modern cremation facilities do not reduce bodies to ashes, but rather to BONES, right? Disingenuously referring to the alleged cremated remains as “ashes” rather than correctly referring to them as bones is a crucial component of this malicious big-lie / cognitive illusion. So if it’s a well known fact that the alleged crude method of burning the bodies could not have made them disappear, then how can anyone in their right mind believe that the simple act of covering the alleged millions of pounds of remaining evidence with dirt do the trick?

And even though the official Treblinka story-line is - the “huge mass graves” were “magically obliterated / utterly eradicated” with a layer of soil - the fraudulent “skeptic” MICHAEL SHERMER claims that he has “scientifically proven” that the phantom physical evidence actually does exist. To illustrate the sophistic machinations that Shermer and his “Skeptics” Society minions have gone through to make this blatantly fraudulent claim, look at these quotes from Shermer’s shamelessly deluding book - Denying History: “The purpose of this book is to… show precisely, with solid evidence… how historians know that it happened as it did… we must obey the rules of reason and apply the tools of science… This process is practiced by all scientists… historical scientists, geologists, paleontologists and archaeologists, to prove that anything in the past happened… We must review the physical evidence.”

What physical evidence? To date, not one mass grave has ever been located at Treblinka and Shermer has yet to prove the existence of one single pound of bone fragments or so much as one single tooth. So if Shermer and all the other orthodox “historians” can’t offer up an iota of tangible physical evidence to back up their claim that Treblinka’s six alleged “huge mass graves” really do exist, then what’s left for them to cling to in justifying their delusional belief in the orthodox version of the story? Why the - a layer of soil can make millions of pounds of evidence magically disappear “theory” - of course! It simply boggles the mind that it’s necessary to explain to adults (just as you would to a three-year-old child), that by covering something up with dirt, you’re not actually making it magically disappear.

“Eyewitness” Yankel Wiernik’s model of the 6 alleged “huge mass graves” of Treblinka that allegedly contain;

Millions of pounds of bone fragments, tens of millions of teeth and tens of thousands of bullets and shell casings.

How hard would it be to locate these alleged “huge mass graves” using modern forensic science techniques?

Especially when you consider the following from Yitzhak Arad’s deluding book - BELZEC, SOBIBOR, TREBLINKA - (chapter 23) - The Erasure of the Crimes: “The camp command was confronted with the problem of disposing of the large piles of ash and bits of bone that remained… Ultimately it was decided to dump the ash and bits of bone into the ditches that had previously held the bodies and to cover them with a thick layer of sand and dirt… [Eyewitness] Abraham Goldfarb relates: …’we secretly placed in the walls of the graves whole skeletons and we wrote on scraps of paper what the Germans were doing at Treblinka. We put the scraps of paper into bottles, which we placed next to the skeletons. Our intention was that if one day someone looked for traces, they could indeed be found.’”

Yes, “traces” could easily be found - IF - the absurd mass burial claims are actually true. (And did you notice the incredible contradiction to the official - “nothing remains, nothing” - story-line?) Yet Shermer accuses real skeptics of “denying history” because they refuse to believe the nonsensical magically disappearing evidence “theory.” In his sophistic and sophomoric attempt to “prove” his accusations, he not only turned the scientific method on its head, but the fundamental principles of skepticism as well. Look again at his own words from Denying History: “To debunk the deniers can’t we just go there and see for ourselves? The answer, of course, is “yes.” We can no longer ignore the deniers… We cannot remain silent anymore. It’s time to respond… We went to Europe to conduct research at… Treblinka, Sobibor, Belzec… We wanted to see for ourselves just what evidence there is at the camps and to take the opportunity to examine firsthand the claims… How is it that so much physical evidence can come to be doubted?”

What physical evidence? And if there is any, then why does Shermer refuse to disclose its location?

Aerial view of the Treblinka monument: Not a trace of human remains was found during its construction.

For further evidence of Shermer’s fraud, notice these DELIBERATE OMISSIONS from - Denying History, the most blatant being this HERE: “It seems inconceivable that you were unaware of the investigations at Treblinka… Or did you suppress them?” For a more thorough treatise on these exculpatory investigations, click HERE: “In August of 1944 the Soviets carried out a thorough forensic investigation at Treblinka. And what did their numerous excavations uncover? Refuse pits - filled with burned and unburned trash. No graves were found - mass or otherwise… Another forensic examination was carried out by the Poles in November of 1945 which included more excavations… ‘The excavations began where, according to the witness, a mass grave was supposed to exist… There were no human remains found… After his investigation, Lukaszkiewicz issued a protocol which was presented by the Soviets at the Nuremberg show trial as Document USSR-344. In said official protocol, Lukaszkiewicz admitted the truth about his investigation of Treblinka with this telling confession: ‘During the work on the terrain, I found no mass graves.’”

So now you know why Shermer fraudulently omitted THE INCONVENIENT FACT that there have been previous on-site forensic investigations conducted at Treblinka which proved that no mass graves exist there. With the help of professional liars like Shermer, all previous exculpatory forensic investigations of Treblinka have been put down the memory hole. And you also now know that there is no physical evidence to support the criminal hoax that the “huge mass graves” have been located. (A brief description of each of the 54 fraudulently alleged “huge mass graves” can be found HERE.) Do you see how easy it is to see through the lies when you open your eyes and think for yourself?

RECAP: Covering millions of pounds of bone fragments and teeth with a layer of soil can “obliterate” all evidence of a crime? Debunked. Shermer’s fraudulent claim that the remains of 1.9 million bodies have been scientifically proven to exist? DEBUNKED: “That's the only way to understand this subject. It has to be studied carefully… If you slow down and look carefully at the logic, his illusion doesn't work… Shermer has set up his argument in such a way that the ordinary methods of logic don't apply… This is like a shell game: you have to watch what he's doing… The Shermer principle is not logic… The jumping together phenomenon is how illusionists produce their illusions.”

NO MASS GRAVES = COGNITIVE ILLUSION

The rules for laying claim to

THE N.A.F.H. CRIME SCENE INVESTIGATION CHALLENGE TM REWARD

$1,000.00 will be awarded for each one of the 54 fraudulently alleged “huge mass graves” that are proven to contain the remains of - at least 19 bodies. To begin the incredibly easy, three-part process of laying claim to the reward:

First - a claimant must contact the N.A.F.H. (see contact information below) and request - and confirm receipt of - the official posting rules. Second - a claimant must post their alleged “proof” that each fraudulently alleged “huge mass grave” contains the remains of at least 19 bodies on - SHERMER'S OWN FORUM. Third - the posted “proof” must then be categorically endorsed by Michael Shermer (the sole appointed arbiter of the challenge), explicitly stating that said posted “proof” meets his own, “Skeptic” Magazine’s and the “Skeptics” Society’s claimed standards of proof.

NOTE: Most of the “proof” that has been used to contrive the cognitive illusion that the 54 “huge mass graves” have been scientifically located / proven to exist is readily available on the internet. So the $54,000.00 question is: How many of the fraudulently alleged 54 “huge mass graves” can you prove contain the remains of at least 19 bodies?

It is a historical fact that not one of the fraudulently alleged “huge mass graves” of Belzec, Chelmno, Sobibor and Treblinka has ever been proven to contain so much as - 1 / 1,000 of 1 % - of the alleged buried bodies; and it is a irrefutable fact that not one single alleged mass grave “proof” ever submitted on Shermer’s forum has ever been endorsed by Shermer as meeting his own, Skeptic Magazine’s and the Skeptics Society’s claimed standards of proof.

* * * * *

All information on this website constitutes a fair use of any copyrighted material as provided

for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. Last updated on 6-11-11. All rights reserved.

For more information, contact the N.A.F.H. at: treblinkafraud@yahoo.com

ADDENDUM